Outsourcing the Design, Not the Risk: A Warning for Contractors and Insurers

Rosenlund Constructions Pty Ltd v Certain Underwriters at Lloyd’s of London Subscribing to Policy Number 08070017 [2026] FCA 1442
November 2 2026

By David Slatyer, Partner and Ciara Broccardo, Lawyer

The Federal Court’s recent decision in Rosenlund Constructions Pty Ltd v Certain Underwriters at Lloyd’s of London Subscribing to Policy Number 08070017 [2026] FCA 1442 (Rosenlund Constructions), Jackman J considered the operation of a professional services exclusion in a public and products liability policy where the insured demolition contractor had engaged consulting engineers to design the relevant demolition methodology. The decision provides important guidance for liability insurers, particularly where insureds assume contractual responsibility for design functions performed by third-party consultants.

Background

The proceedings arose out of the demolition of the former Sydney Entertainment Centre (Qantas Credit Union Arena) pursuant to a subcontract between Lendlease and H Hassarati & Co Pty Ltd (Hassarati). Hassarati’s scope of work extended beyond physical demolition and included responsibility for designing and documenting demolition methodology and temporary works. The subcontract required Hassarati to exercise professional skill, care and diligence and to procure structural engineering input where necessary.

Hassarati engaged consulting engineers to prepare aspects of the demolition methodology. During the demolition works, part of the structure collapsed in an unplanned manner, resulting in substantial property damage and associated losses. Claims were subsequently made against Hassarati, which sought indemnity under its public and products liability policy.

Insurers declined indemnity relying principally on a professional services exclusion, contending that the liability arose from professional advice, design and engineering services for which Hassarati was contractually responsible.

The Central Issue – Professional Services Exclusion

The central issue was whether the claims against Hassarati arose out of the rendering of professional advice or professional services such that the exclusion operated to remove cover under the public and products liability policy.

Hassarati contended that it was fundamentally a demolition contractor and that the relevant engineering and design work had been undertaken by external consultants. It argued that any liability arose from construction and demolition activities rather than the provision of professional services.

Insurers submitted that Hassarati’s contractual obligations extended beyond physical demolition works and included responsibility for reviewing, adopting and implementing the demolition design. As a result, the losses arose from professional services notwithstanding that aspects of the design work had been performed by third-party engineers.

The Court’s Approach

Jackman J emphasised that whether conduct constitutes a professional service depends upon the nature of the obligations undertaken by the insured and the role it was retained to perform. His Honour rejected the proposition that a contractor could avoid characterisation as providing professional services merely because specialist consultants had prepared the relevant design documentation.

The Court examined the subcontract as a whole and found that Hassarati had assumed responsibility for the demolition methodology and associated temporary works. Although consulting engineers were engaged to prepare engineering designs, Hassarati remained contractually responsible for assessing, adopting and implementing those designs in carrying out the demolition works.

Importantly, the Court held that the professional services exclusion was engaged because the claims had a sufficient causal connection with those professional obligations. The phrase “arising out of” required only a causal or consequential relationship and did not require the professional services to be the sole, dominant or proximate cause of the loss.

The Court also rejected the argument that no professional service was provided “for a fee” because the contract did not separately identify remuneration for design work. His Honour held that professional services may be provided for a fee where they form part of a broader contractual scope for which consideration is paid, even if no discrete fee is allocated to the professional component of the works.

Accordingly, the exclusion operated to preclude indemnity.

Key Takeaways for Insurers

The decision contains several important lessons for insurers.

  • The decision in Rosenlund Constructions highlights that a contractor may still be providing professional services even when it engages an external consultant to undertake those services. This is especially true where the contract requires the contractor to exercise its own professional skill and judgment.
  • Insuring clauses and exclusions must be “read together in a harmonious way” so that effect is given to both.
  • When considering whether a professional advice or services exclusion applies, the court will closely examine what the insured was contractually retained to do. Responsibility for reviewing, adopting or warranting a consultant’s design may be sufficient to bring the insured’s conduct within the exclusion.
  • Passing on an incorrect design without checking it is not merely administrative. It can constitute professional conduct.
  • Jackman J held that “arising out of” does not require a proximate cause, only a causal or consequential link.
  • The case also demonstrates that a professional service may be given “for a fee” even where the contract does not allocate a separate amount to design or professional services. Payment of the overall contract price may be sufficient.

Conclusion

Rosenlund Constructions confirms that courts will focus on the substance of the insured’s obligations rather than the labels attached to it or the fact that specialist consultants were engaged. Where a contractor assumes responsibility for professional advice/services, such as design, engineering or methodological decisions, liabilities arising from those functions may be excluded from the scope of public and products liability cover.