Litig8: High Court reconsiders advocate’s immunity

July, 2016

By Harrison Wall, Lawyer

Each month as a part of Mills Oakley’s Litig8, we bring to you snapshots of eight key cases, legislative changes or other legal events. The summaries are not comprehensive and do not constitute legal advice. You should seek professional advice before taking any action based on the content of this email.

Part 6 of Litig8 July edition

The High Court recently confirmed that the advocates’ immunity is not satisfied where the work of the advocate leads to an agreement between parties to litigation to settle their dispute which are subsequently embodied in consent orders.

In Atwells v Jackson Lalic Lawyers Pty Ltd [2016] HCA 16, the first appellant and another had been involved in proceedings against the ANZ bank regarding the guarantee for payments of liabilities of a company. Their former solicitors advised them to enter into a settlement agreement to settle the claim and accept liability for an amount larger than that limited under the guarantee. The terms of the settlement were reflected in a consent order for judgment made by the Court.

The appellants sued their former solicitors in negligence for the advice provided in relation to the settlement agreement. The solicitors relied on the advocates’ immunity. The appellants argued that the immunity should be abolished at law or, in the alternative, should not extend to advice which leads to the settlement of the case by agreement between the parties.

A majority of the High Court held that the basis of the advocates’ immunity is the protection of the finality and certainty of judicial determinations. The immunity requires an “intimate connection” between the advocate’s work and the conduct of the case in court. A settlement agreement does not as a matter of fact fall within the principles. It is concerned only with work by the advocate that bears upon the judge’s determination of the case.

In relation to the consent order which embodied the agreement, the majority held that although the consent order may, by the rules of court, be given the same legal effect as an order made after a hearing in court, the judge in this case had made no finding of fact or law which resolved the controversy between parties and could not be said to bear upon the judicial determination of the judge. The agreement was comprised of terms as settled between the parties only.

Contact Mills Oakley

Melbourne

andrew-brown

Andrew Brown | Partner
T: +61 3 9605 0961
E: abrown@millsoakley.com.au

ariel-borland

Ariel Borland | Partner

T: +61 3 9605 0015
E: aborland@millsoakley.com.au

darren-james

Darren James | Partner
T: +61 3 9605 0952
E: djames@millsoakley.com.au

james-tobin

James Tobin | Partner
T: +61 3 9605 0851
E: jtobin@millsoakley.com.au

joanne-hardwick

Joanne Hardwick | Partner
T: +61 3 9605 0949
E: jhardwick@millsoakley.com.au

mark-wenn

Mark Wenn | Partner
T: +61 3 9605 0913
E: mwenn@millsoakley.com.au

roger-jepson

Roger Jepson | Partner
T: +61 3 9605 0899
E: rjepson@millsoakley.com.au

stuart-lewin

Stuart Lewin | Partner
T: +61 3 9605 0986
E: slewin@millsoakley.com.au

Canberra

mark-flint

Mark Flint | Partner
T: +61 2 6196 5217
E: mdflint@millsoakley.com.au

matthew-roser

Matthew Roser | Partner
T: +61 2 6196 5229
E: mroser@millsoakley.com.au

Sydney

damian-ward

Damian Ward | Partner
T: +61 2 8289 5862
E: dward@millsoakley.com.au

gerard-breen

Gerard Breen | Partner
T: +61 2 8035 7888
E: gbreen@millsoakley.com.au

jeremy-mackenzie

Jeremy Mackenzie | Partner
T: +61 2 8289 5807
E: jmackenzie@millsoakley.com.au


peter-hodges

Peter Hodges | Partner
T: +61 2 8035 7845
E: phodges@millsoakley.com.au

mark-tierney

Mark Tierney | Special Counsel
T: +61 2 8035 7920
E: mtierney@millsoakley.com.au

Perth

craig-gough

Craig Gough | Partner
T: +61 8 6167 9807
E: cgough@millsoakley.com.au

Brisbane

dale-cliff

Dale Cliff | Partner
T: +61 7 3228 0430
E: dcliff@millsoakley.com.au

 

samuel-barber

Samuel Barber | Special Counsel
T: +61 7 3228 0477
E: sbarber@millsoakley.com.au

stephen-dickens

Stephen Dickens | Partner
T: +61 7 3228 0445
E: sdickens@millsoakley.com.au

Privacy Policy | Terms of Use